| Store | Storenumber | Storename | Location | Address | City | Opened | Closed | Storetype | Floorarea | Replaced | ReplacedBy | Previous | Next |
|---|
| Payless ShoeSource 4223 | 4223 | | Aguadilla Mall (Aguadilla, Puerto Rico) | 15005 Avenue Los Corazones (Aguadilla, Puerto Rico) | Aguadilla, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 4,681 square feet (434.9 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4221 | 4221 | | Plaza Del Atlantico (Arecibo, Puerto Rico) | 1400 Avenue Miramar (Arecibo, Puerto Rico) | Arecibo, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,302 square feet (306.8 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 2868 | 2868 | | Santa Rosa Mall (Bayamon, Puerto Rico) | 1455 Carretera 2 (Bayamon, Puerto Rico) | Bayamon, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 2,802 square feet (260.3 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4250 | 4250 | | Plaza Del Sol Mall (Bayamon, Puerto Rico) | 725 Avenue West Main (Bayamon, Puerto Rico) | Bayamon, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,411 square feet (316.9 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4159 | 4159 | | Rexville Towne Center (Bayamon, Puerto Rico) | 3009 Carretera 167 (Bayamon, Puerto Rico) | Bayamon, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,000 square feet (280 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4242 | 4242 | | Plaza Rio Hondo Mall (Bayamon, Puerto Rico) | 60 Avenue Rio Hondo (Bayamon, Puerto Rico) | Bayamon, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,750 square feet (348 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4992 | 4992 | | Plaza Centro 1 (Caguas, Puerto Rico) | 200 Avenue Rafael Cordero (Caguas, Puerto Rico) | Caguas, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,000 square feet (280 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4248 | 4248 | | Las Catalinas Mall (Caguas, Puerto Rico) | Calle Betances 410 (Caguas, Puerto Rico) | Caguas, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,164 square feet (293.9 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 3749 | 3749 | | The Outlet 66 Mall (Canovanas, Puerto Rico) | 18400 State Road No 3 (Canovanas, Puerto Rico) | Canovanas, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 2,929 square feet (272.1 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4253 | 4253 | | Plaza Escorial (Carolina, Puerto Rico) | 5840 Plaza Escorial (Carolina, Puerto Rico) | Carolina, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,521 square feet (327.1 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4247 | 4247 | | Los Colobos Shopping Center (Carolina, Puerto Rico) | 14220 Avenue 65 Infanteria (Carolina, Puerto Rico) | Carolina, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,200 square feet (300 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 141 | 141 | | Plaza Carolina (Carolina, Puerto Rico) | 65 Infantry (Carolina, Puerto Rico) | Carolina, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 7,390 square feet (687 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4245 | 4245 | | Perez Hermanos Plaza (Cayey, Puerto Rico) | 4007 Avenue Jesus T Pinero (Cayey, Puerto Rico) | Cayey, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,200 square feet (300 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4206 | 4206 | | Plaza Fajardo (Fajardo, Puerto Rico) | 150 Carretera 940 (Fajardo, Puerto Rico) | Fajardo, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,200 square feet (300 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4239 | 4239 | | San Patricio Plaza (Guaynabo, Puerto Rico) | 100 Avenue San Patricio (Guaynabo, Puerto Rico) | Guaynabo, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,300 square feet (310 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4255 | 4255 | | Plaza Guaynabo Shopping Center (Guaynabo, Puerto Rico) | Calle Marginal Esmeralda (Guaynabo, Puerto Rico) | Guaynabo, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,380 square feet (314 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4215 | 4215 | | Plaza Del Norte Mall (Hatillo, Puerto Rico) | 506 Calle Truncado (Hatillo, Puerto Rico) | Hatillo, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 4,252 square feet (395.0 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4235 | 4235 | | Plaza Isabela (Isabela, Puerto Rico) | 3535 Avenue Militar (Isabela, Puerto Rico) | Isabela, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,000 square feet (280 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 1836 | 1836 | | Manati Plaza (Manati, Puerto Rico) | 10 Carretera 149 (Manati, Puerto Rico) | Manati, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 2,710 square feet (252 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4213 | 4213 | | Mayaguez Mall (Mayaguez, Puerto Rico) | 975 Avenue Hostos (Mayaguez, Puerto Rico) | Mayaguez, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,500 square feet (330 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 3286 | 3286 | | Mercado Plaza (Naranjito, Puerto Rico) | El 33 Pr 152 K (Naranjito, Puerto Rico) | Naranjito, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 2,545 square feet (236.4 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4260 | 4260 | | Centro Del Sur Mall (Ponce, Puerto Rico) | 1485 Boulevard Miguel Pou (Ponce, Puerto Rico) | Ponce, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 2,912 square feet (270.5 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4205 | 4205 | | Plaza Del Caribe (Ponce, Puerto Rico) | 2050 Ponce Bypass (Ponce, Puerto Rico) | Ponce, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 4,354 square feet (404.5 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4238 | 4238 | | The Outlets at Montehiedra (Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico) | 9410 Avenue Los Romeros (Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico) | Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,048 square feet (283.2 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 286 | 286 | | Plaza Las Americas (San Juan, Puerto Rico) | 525 Roosevelt Avenue (San Juan, Puerto Rico) | San Juan, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 6,467 square feet (600.8 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4156 | 4156 | | 65th Infantry Shopping Center (San Juan, Puerto Rico) | Avenida 65 Infanteria (San Juan, Puerto Rico) | San Juan, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,026 square feet (281.1 m2) | | | | |
| Payless ShoeSource 4164 | 4164 | | | Plaza Caribe Mall (Vega Alta, Puerto Rico) | Vega Alta, Puerto Rico | | 2019 | | 3,576 square feet (332.2 m2) | | | | |